Wednesday, September 3, 2008

The black cloud of Depression.

Depression envelopes you like a black cloud. It fills you with sorrow, despair and hopelessness. I can remember many depressed persons who ultimately ended their lives. The last in the list is a class mate of my brother. He was qualified as a lawyer, but preferred to do agriculture in the small piece of land owned by his family. His story is similar to the tales usually reported by news papers (and cliched !). But black letters on white surface cannot express the innermost feelings of the survivors.

In most of such cases we see a combination of debt due to financial mismanagement / indiscipline, failure of the government and other agencies in providing adequate remuneration for their crops, alcohol misuse, impulsive and risk taking approach to life and a blind optimism that 'in the end God will save me as i mean no harm to others'. This optimism turns into total lack of hope and trust when things go wrong, and the person plunges into the abyss of despair. As I pointed out earlier majority of them suffer from Clinical depression towards the end of their life.
The prominent feature of the depression are
1) Sadness or depressed mood
2) Anhedonia or the inability to derive pleasure from things which were pleasureful earlier.
3) Lack of energy, tiredness and becoming easily fatigued.
Difficulty to fall asleep, or waking up after midnight or much earlier than usual is another symptom. Lack of sexual desire, pessimistic thoughts, poor appetite and weight loss are other prominent features.
Depression also can have other presentations. In some it may present as severe anxiety and worries. Some depressed persons self medicate themselves with alcohol as this boosts up their mood transiently.

Sometimes it wears the mask of a physical illness - 'masked depression'. Such patients consult many doctors with multiple bodily complaints. Doctors cant diagnose any illness as physical examination and investigations are 'within normal limits'. These patients are using the language of their body to express their emotional distress. May be due to a thought that doctors will only listen to bodily complaints. Sometimes the sufferer may not be clear about what is wrong. The fatigue and lack of energy due to depression may be thought of as a bodily problem. Doctors fail to ask questions about one's emotional state as they are not tuned to it or do not know what to ask.

As training offered in psychiatry is only namesake in most of the Indian medical colleges, they are ill equipped to deal with emotional problems. MB BS course does not have any examinations in Psychiatry. But paradoxically, both General Nursing and Midwifery and B Sc Nursing courses have theory and practical examination in Psychiatry. So it may be a better idea to go to a nurse when one feels depressed and is mortally scared of psychiatrists.

There are studies showing that 40% of people who attempt suicide had consulted their doctors within one week of the attempt. Probably with bodily complaints which were the masks of their depression. But doctors failed to penetrate beneath the facade of the symptoms and understand the cry for help. There is also evidence to show that the best way to reduce suicide rates is by educating general practitioners how to detect and treat depression.
Depression is an eminently treatable condition. Options available include antidepressant drugs and psychological methods. There is evidence to show that combination of both is beneficial in moderate depression than one modality alone.

2 comments:

Devadas said...

Depression....
It is a feeling,which everybody experience ...and the intensity and frequency vary depending upon the personality and living enviornment..
Varying moods make life wonderful;
If one can develop/acquire a detached feeling towards these dark shadows/depression which engulf our mind temporarily, we would be able to tolerate the pain of depression better...like watching the green earth covered with the moving shadows of clouds from a slow moving aeroplane stationed above!
Happyness is just another mood of our mind which everybody wishes to have permenetly !In a way all our efforts/struggles of life are powered by the hope that "permenent happyness out in the future"....

Eventhough these are feelings of a dynamic mind which is virtual, we believe/consider them as very very real, to the extend of committing to destroy the whole system of our life (suicide)along with our precious mind which has the ultimate survival instinct!
Suicide tendency is in-built in our mind ; at some point of our judgement is starts operating as a terminator gene....and society try to limit it .....
TO me the best prescription would be the recognition of the useless ness of " hope" which is false ....beyond doubt!

*********
I have a small suggestion/project to the psychiatrists and their organisations who work in the field of Suicide.

Is it possible for you to exchange the patients/failed people, to a totally new place ,who can not continue their life in the present enviornment as 'memory can not be erased from the mind of other people around them"...?
exchange programme.. can we offer a second life to people who have failed in their original locality and will be able to start a new life in a totally new place?
For example if you have tie up with Vellore,and have a rehabilitation centre at Calicut, we can accept people who have decided to end their life at Vellore : and in turn you can send your patients to Vellore! If so far no body has done such an experiment with failed people ,I wish if you could start one such Harish!

Dr. Harish. M. Tharayil said...

Thanks for the comments, Devadas. I think it is better to view the suicidal person's belief that his life is a failure as the result of a pathological process. This is the result of what professionals call "cognitive errors". At no point in life things are that bad that one has to end one's life. This decision is taken as a result of distorted thinking. Several cognitive errors have been described. Arbitrary inference, selctive abstraction, magnifying one's problems, minimizing one's poential and support of others etc are come of the errors. Some of this is discussed in an earlier post on anxiety and OCD. I shall discuss more on this in a subsequent post.